Grid Security Now!

Grid Security Now!

Michael Mabee – Author of The Civil Defense Book

Menu
  • Home
  • Library
    • Grid Security Library
      • Government Documents on Grid Security
      • OE-417 Electric Disturbance Events Database
      • CIP Violation Database
      • Grid Protection Posts
      • Video (EMP and Grid Security)
      • What is the Electric Grid and How is it Regulated?
    • Civil Defense Library
      • Civil Defense Posts
      • Video (Preparedness)
      • Civil Defense Checklists
  • Fund The Fight!
  • Take Action!
  • About Me
    • About Michael
    • My Book
    • Michael in the Press
    • Subscribe to Mike’s Blog
    • Interviews
    • My Friends
    • Contact Me
Menu

Metcalf Attack: NBC Reports on PG&E Security Memo

Posted on April 5, 2016March 27, 2018 by Michael Mabee
Share the knowledge...Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
Pin on Pinterest
Pinterest
Share on Reddit
Reddit
Email this to someone
email
Print this page
Print

 

 

NBC Bay Area reports on a leaked PG&E memo regarding security of substations after the Metcalf attack.

PG&E Memo: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2081637-pg-amp-e-memo-august-30-2014.html

Transcript from NBC Bay Area website:

An internal Pacific Gas & Electric Corporation memo obtained by NBC Bay Area shows the company is years away from promised security upgrades at its electrical substations.

The company made promises to bolster security at critical facilities after a dramatic automatic-weapons attack on its Metcalf substation in South San Jose more than two years ago. Since then, the company claimed that it has increased security at key substations and that more changes are coming soon. The director of corporate security said publicly that PG&E has “high level security” at critical facilities.

This new information casts doubt on those prior statements and raises concerns about the company’s ability to provide security for the California electrical grid. The memo was provided to the Investigative Unit by PG&E insiders who wanted this information out.

Last August, Stephanie Douglas, the director of the Corporate Security Division (CSD), wrote to PG&E president Chris Johns that “the physical security infrastructure of PG&E has plenty of work to be done.”

“In reality,” she wrote, “PG&E is years away from a healthy and robust physical security posture.”

Just 12 days before that, Douglas told the Investigative Unit a very different story.

“For our critical facilities right now we have high level security there—yes,” she said.

In April 2013, snipers attacked the Metcalf substation in South San Jose. The attack caused millions in damages and could have blacked out much of Silicon Valley.

Although federal law enforcement officials have not officially labelled the attack an act of terrorism, many high-ranking government officials have speculated that it may have been a trial run for a more robust attack. Authorities have yet to capture the gunmen.

In June 2014, PG&E committed to spending $100 million over three years to harden security at the Metcalf substation and several other critical facilities.

An NBC Bay Area investigation last July discovered that security was still lacking at many electric substations a year and a half after the attack at Metcalf. In 14 unannounced visits to nine substations in Northern and Central California, the Investigative Unit revealed what experts have called vulnerabilities in PG&E’s security network.

A month later, on August 18, Douglas provided an interview to the Investigative Unit to discuss whether PG&E had done enough to prevent another event like the Metcalf attack.

“We are working every day to make sure it never happens again,” Douglas said at the time.

Then, on August 27, the Metcalf substation experienced a second security breach. Unidentified intruders cut through a fence and stole expensive equipment. PG&E’s “high level security” had failed to produce any public photos or video of the break in.

On August 30—12 days after the interview and three days after the second security breach at Metcalf—Douglas sent a memo to Johns describing the significant challenges facing her division.

She wrote that CSD had not received enough resources to make significant improvements at substations and that the allocation of resources “remained unchanged from before the attack on Metcalf.”

She added, “These improvements continue to be slow, piecemeal and uncertain” and “We risk not knowing about security issues and having gaps exist for some time before the issue is resolved.”

In the memo Douglas also wrote that CSD couldn’t account for existing security assets. “The company’s existing security infrastructure is an assortment of technologies, many of them outdated. They have been cobbled together over the past 25 years and I would consider them to be in a ‘fail’ mode.”

State Senator Jerry Hill has criticized PG&E for security failings, including the fatal pipeline explosion in San Bruno in 2010. Since then, the utility company has pledged a commitment to safety and security. Hill says the memo calls PG&E’s integrity into question.

“They’ve said they were going to change. They’ve committed to change, but they haven’t changed,” he said.

Hill authored successful legislation requiring greater requirements and accountability for security at PG&E substations.

“This memo clearly states that PG&E had not done and hadn’t had the resources to do what was necessary to provide the security of their infrastructure,” Hill said. “It clearly says that she did not tell us the facts of the situation.”

Douglas and PG&E representatives declined new interview requests to discuss the contradictions in public statements and the private memo. Instead, the company sent an email detailing changes to security since Douglas sent the memo. They include more funding and staffing for security and monthly progress updates for senior managers.

PG&E also points to significant security upgrades at the Metcalf substation. In early 2015 the company built a barrier wall around the substation, enhanced its detection and deterrent systems and improved lighting.

It is unclear when PG&E will make major improvements to other critical substations. As Douglas wrote in the memo the company is still years away from a “robust physical security posture.”

“We don’t have years for security,” said Hill. “This could be drastic and devastating for our economy and for many people’s lives if we lose some of these substations.”

Substation Security Timeline
In an internal memo from PG&E revealed that the company was years away from promised security upgrades. Just a few days before, she told the NBC Bay Area Investigative Unit that there was already “high-level” security at critical facilities. Here’s a timeline of our investigations.

Share the knowledge...Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
Pin on Pinterest
Pinterest
Share on Reddit
Reddit
Email this to someone
email
Print this page
Print

News

  • A Billion Reasons We Do Not Have Grid Security
  • Money Talks, Grid Security Walks
  • Critical Infrastructure Attacks Expose Regulatory Failures
  • Lawsuit: The Federal Government Must Secure The Grid
  • COVERUP UPDATE: CIP Violation Database and FOIAs
  • Securing America with Frank Gaffney: Threats to the Electric Grid
  • FERC: Who Will Be Responsible For All The Deaths If The Grid Goes Down?
  • Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Lays Down On The Job!
  • EMP Progress Report – A National Disgrace
  • EMP Ignorance Is Bliss – Dr. Peter Vincent Pry
  • China: EMP Threat – A New Report by Dr. Peter Pry
  • FERC Denies Grid Physical Security Complaint, BUT…
  • Secure the Grid Coalition Opposes Senate Bill S.3688
  • Electric Industry Lobbyist’s China Ties Questioned
  • Supply Chain Cybersecurity Complaint Filed with FERC
  • Executive Order 13920: Securing the United States Bulk-Power System
  • Electric Industry Wants to Defer Implementation of Cybersecurity
  • Electric Sector Protests Effective Grid Physical Security
  • Emergency Preparedness: Souhegan and Derry CERT
  • Coronavirus: Don’t Panic, Prepare!
  • New Hampshire Rep. David Testerman on Grid Physical Security
  • Former CIA Director James Woolsey on Grid Physical Security
  • Loopholes in Grid Physical Security Identified
  • FEMA’s Strategic Plan and the NDAA: A Perfect Fit
  • Greg Allison and Michael Mabee Talk Grid Security On YouTube
  • Complaint Filed About Inadequate Electric Grid Physical Security
  • Is the Tail Wagging The Dog in Grid Security?
  • Video: EMP Threat (KSNV News Las Vegas)
  • Why Thomas Popik should be a FERC Commissioner
  • “Wired for Greed: The Shocking Truth About America’s Electric Utilities”

Fund The Fight!


Subjects

Search Website

Subscribe for Updates!

Follow me on Twitter

Tweets by CivilDefenseBK

Click To Get Prepared!

The Civil Defense Book: Emergency Preparedness for a Rural or Suburban Community
The Civil Defense Book Get it now!

Subscribe for updates

Follow Me On Facebook

The Civil Defense Book

4 days ago

The Civil Defense Book
Russia, Iran and China exploit Capitol Hill riot to push information operations, US intel concludeswww.cyberscoop.com/capitol-riot-russia-china-iran-biden-inauguration/ ...

Russia, Iran and China exploit Capitol Hill riot to push information operations, US intel concludes - CyberScoop

www.cyberscoop.com

As America reels from the deadly Capitol Hill insurrection, Russia, Iran and China are using their state media mouthpieces to exploit U.S. divisions and further their interests ahead of Joe Biden’s inauguration, according to a new U.S. intelligence analysis obtained by CyberScoop. The Jan. 14 inte...
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

The Civil Defense Book

6 days ago

The Civil Defense Book
Kim Jong Un Offers a Rare Sneak Peek at North Korea’s Weapons Program: Leader says Pyongyang is developing military drones, a nuclear-powered submarine and surveillance satellites. apple.news/AEW8HnWOTS0Wk23aOI9fZ1g ...

Kim Jong Un Offers a Rare Sneak Peek at North Korea’s Weapons Program — The Wall Street Journal

apple.news

As President-elect Joe Biden prepares to take office, Kim Jong Un offered details on Pyongyang’s pipeline of military hardware during a rare Workers’ Party Congress meeting that ended this week.
View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

Fund The fight!


©2021 Grid Security Now! | Theme by SuperbThemes